Wolter KOOPS truck confiscated

orys:
500 years ago people used to think that Earth is flat and in the centre of the Universe. Then one Polish chap, named Mikołaj Kopernik, proved them wrong. Oh, the irony :slight_smile:

Sigh…The Ancient Greeks knew the Earth was not flat, they also knew it wasn’t the centre of the Universe ,not sure where you get these facts from. But if you have some spare time, pop over to Wikepidia and sort out the controversey for them as they seem to have some doubt that Kopernik was Polish, infact they think he was German.
Now i’m sure you checked these facts thoroughly as indeed you did your others and VOSA are unfairly targeting EE trucks

He’ll convince us Hitler was Polish next!

orys:

merc0447:
Sure vosa just profile the same way security do at airports or the police do to young black men. Nothing racist in it, it just using the limited manpower to get maximum results.

Pull over 100 British wagons
Pull over 100 foreign wagons

and the foreigners will get more results so next time pull over 200 foreign wagons.

Yes, but the thing is that, as someone (not me!) pointed out, they won’t get more results from foreigners, because they will have about the same percentage of offenders as Britons do.

Trust me Orys that’s not true. The reason they pull more foreigners is because they are getting a higher percentage of offenses, note percentage not pure numbers. It’s far easier and less costly for VOSA to deal with UK vehicles and drivers. They also have a far greater number of sticks with which to beat the UK operator. Look for instance at Nolans. Thousands of prohibitions yet they cannot be kept from British roads. Were that Joe Smith Haulage of Glasgow it would be bye bye O licence and the drivers may well suffer vocational licence penalties as well. So it would actually make sense to pull more UK hauliers BUT as we have all these other layers of punishment and regulation the fact is less of them are found to be offenders.
Many of the offences actually result from a lack of harmonisation. A vehicle that was legal for the first part of it’s journey may suddenly be 1,000kgs over weight on the pin. Sounds very dramatic but it’s well within manufacturers safe thresholds and that of other EU countries. You could also load up to 40,000kgs but forget that you will be filling up with a big chunk of diesel before crossing the channel.
Likewise with say the rules in regard to wing tops on mudguards and how VOSA call that one, so again legal perhaps until you get off the ferry.
Not that this excuses the offences, as a good driver should know and account for all these factors but if your VOSA and have the axle weighers out, guess what’s going over them ■■ Many accomplished mainland European drivers may be blissfully unaware of a lot of these issues.

Also the UK authorities have made great efforts to knock off things like per KM pay, unpaid waiting time etc where as that is, as you say, still prevalent in some EE countries. Despite a small minority of ■■■■■■■■ cowboys most UK operators are these days so [zb] scared of losing there O licence that things are squeakier clean than ever. In many instances the EE drivers who get caught are under tremendous pressure from employers in much the same way some of us were 10 or 20 years ago.

It’s not a racist thing at all. It’s the simple truth. As I said earlier nobody, well not me anyway :laughing: , is saying all EE drivers are bad but your dogged defence of undeniable truths really ruins what I consider to be the good discussion we’re having here, Orys.
As I’ve said with the immigration thing as a whole, it’s OK to hate the game but not the players. In this case the players are stuck in a bad but slowly improving game as we were once. :wink:

Happy Polish Independence day, by the way :smiley:

Wasnt Hitler jewish?

jammymutt:
Wasnt Hitler jewish?

From reading Mein Kampf (his own book) it appears he wasn’t ! :smiley:

He was…Rabbi Adolf Hitlergoldstein from Wroclaw. FACT :smiley:

A couple of myths exposed in the latest from VOSA:

A quarter of all trucks stopped are illegal

British-registered trucks stopped by VOSA are just as likely to be unroadworthy or being driven by drivers who have exceeded their hours as foreign ones, according to the latest figures from the agency.
In both cases, about one-in-four of the trucks stopped were judged unfit for the road and about eight per cent of drivers were over hours.
VOSA had 29,857 ‘roadside encounters’ with GB-registered trucks and 26,196 with overseas ones. Foreign trucks are therefore far more likely overall to be stopped, and the selection for inspection is more random as intelligence about the conformance of foreign operators is patchy.

Agency takes hard line on cabotage

VOSA has renewed its commitment to expelling foreign-registered trucks found working illegally on combined transport and cabotage operations in Great Britain.
After successfully defending an appeal by Nolan Transport of Ireland against the impounding of two of its trucks VOSA said it would continue to send vehicles found working illegally straight out of the country by the nearest exit port, and would impound repeat offenders. The onus would be on the truck operator to ensure that documentation proving the work being undertaken was legal was carried on the truck: operators would not be given the chance to produce the paperwork after the event.
“Without these documents being carried on the vehicle, the vehicle is operating outside of the rules,” a VOSA spokesman said. “VOSA will strictly enforce the law with repeat offenders who try to undermine the competitiveness of GB operators on home ground, and will do so confident in the wholehearted support of the law courts.”

GasGas:
A couple of myths exposed in the latest from VOSA:

A quarter of all trucks stopped are illegal

British-registered trucks stopped by VOSA are just as likely to be unroadworthy or being driven by drivers who have exceeded their hours as foreign ones, according to the latest figures from the agency.
In both cases, about one-in-four of the trucks stopped were judged unfit for the road and about eight per cent of drivers were over hours.
VOSA had 29,857 ‘roadside encounters’ with GB-registered trucks and 26,196 with overseas ones. Foreign trucks are therefore far more likely overall to be stopped, and the selection for inspection is more random as intelligence about the conformance of foreign operators is patchy.

What was your source for this? According to VOSA’s annual report and account for 2010/2011…

Building on the effectiveness of the GB Operator Compliance Risk Score (OCRS) the non-GB
OCRS was rolled out to our roadside examiners at the end of July 2010.

From my understanding all enforcement is targetted and not random, this alone makes it hard to assimilate random sample groups from specified targets?

Mike-C:

GasGas:
A couple of myths exposed in the latest from VOSA:

A quarter of all trucks stopped are illegal

British-registered trucks stopped by VOSA are just as likely to be unroadworthy or being driven by drivers who have exceeded their hours as foreign ones, according to the latest figures from the agency.
In both cases, about one-in-four of the trucks stopped were judged unfit for the road and about eight per cent of drivers were over hours.
VOSA had 29,857 ‘roadside encounters’ with GB-registered trucks and 26,196 with overseas ones. Foreign trucks are therefore far more likely overall to be stopped, and the selection for inspection is more random as intelligence about the conformance of foreign operators is patchy.

What was your source for this? According to VOSA’s annual report and account for 2010/2011…

Building on the effectiveness of the GB Operator Compliance Risk Score (OCRS) the non-GB
OCRS was rolled out to our roadside examiners at the end of July 2010.

From my understanding all enforcement is targetted and not random, this alone makes it hard to assimilate random sample groups from specified targets?

So if that’s accurate despite 3,000 less foreign vehicles being stopped they are more likely to be stopped ■■?
Also if UK operators are targeted on intelligence and 1 in 4 are dodgy but foreign vehicles are stopped without intelligence yet again 1 in 4 are offenders then to me that would suggest foreign vehicles are far more likely to be offenders ■■?

Clear as mud then :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

It’s simply that the data isn’t as robust.

Without the ANPR to tell them who the truck is registered to, no data on performance at annual test, may only see a very small proportion of a particular fleet in the UK at all, may not even be clear who operates the truck at all when it is selected for inspection etc.

billybigrig:

Mike-C:

GasGas:
A couple of myths exposed in the latest from VOSA:

A quarter of all trucks stopped are illegal

British-registered trucks stopped by VOSA are just as likely to be unroadworthy or being driven by drivers who have exceeded their hours as foreign ones, according to the latest figures from the agency.
In both cases, about one-in-four of the trucks stopped were judged unfit for the road and about eight per cent of drivers were over hours.
VOSA had 29,857 ‘roadside encounters’ with GB-registered trucks and 26,196 with overseas ones. Foreign trucks are therefore far more likely overall to be stopped, and the selection for inspection is more random as intelligence about the conformance of foreign operators is patchy.

What was your source for this? According to VOSA’s annual report and account for 2010/2011…

Building on the effectiveness of the GB Operator Compliance Risk Score (OCRS) the non-GB
OCRS was rolled out to our roadside examiners at the end of July 2010.

From my understanding all enforcement is targetted and not random, this alone makes it hard to assimilate random sample groups from specified targets?

So if that’s accurate despite 3,000 less foreign vehicles being stopped they are more likely to be stopped ■■?
Also if UK operators are targeted on intelligence and 1 in 4 are dodgy but foreign vehicles are stopped without intelligence yet again 1 in 4 are offenders then to me that would suggest foreign vehicles are far more likely to be offenders ■■?

Clear as mud then :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

that’s about right.

Obviously there are far less foreign LGVs on the road than British (we are talking about entire vehicle population from 3.5 tonnes up) they ARE more likely to be stopped than Brits, and the Brits that DO get stopped are more lightly to be those with previous, as they can now call up the OCRS using the ANPR camera.

Roadworthiness check results for 2008/9

Checks ----------------- Prohibitions ---------------- %Rate
UK 64,817 ----------------- 21,103 --------------- 32.6%

Foreign 61,039 ----------------- 24,493 --------------- 40.1%

Most up to date I can find but this would also be before UK operators were subject to OCRS targeting too

dft.gov.uk/vosa/repository/2 … Report.pdf Page 15

These figures are an improvement on the previous years for both foreign and domestic HGVs

jammymutt:
Wasnt Hitler jewish?

Remind me again is Jewish a nationality or a religion?

The fabled land of Jewshire is not on my map!

Wheel Nut:

jammymutt:
Wasnt Hitler jewish?

Remind me again is Jewish a nationality or a religion?

The fabled land of Jewshire is not on my map!

Clearly you haven’t heard about the bus conductor who got sacked for yelling “next stop Palastine Road, West Yidsbury” in Manchester many moons ago :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

Mike-C:
Sigh…The Ancient Greeks knew the Earth was not flat, they also knew it wasn’t the centre of the Universe ,not sure where you get these facts from.

From the sources that happen to notice that between Ancient Greece and 1500s there was around 1500 years of Christianity, and that Christianity was spreading their version with fire of sword. The books like Aristarch’s works and Ptolemeus astronomical works were banned. Ever seen “The name of the Rose” with Sean Connery?
Even in the times of Kopernik it was still dangerous to say things like that - this is why he allowed his book to be printed only when he was on his death bed.

Some Wikipedia pages for you: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Galileo_Galilei
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Giordano_Bruno

But if you have some spare time, pop over to Wikepidia and sort out the controversey for them as they seem to have some doubt that Kopernik was Polish, infact they think he was German.

They might think so, but the facts will prove them otherwise. You know, since Kopernik is one of the biggest Poles in history, every child learns about him at school. But especially for you, I do some mini-research. I have acutally to prepare something for my Czech oral class, so I can do the stuff about Kopernik. So, lets see:

  1. Kopernik’s father was Polish. His name was also MikoÅ‚aj. He was from a family of Kraków merchants but he moved to ToruÅ„ after he was asked to lend some money to the city to help it fighting the Teutonic Knights known also as Deutschherrenorden. Deutsch means German in German, in case that you don’t know.
    Kopernik family was from Silesia, from the small village of Koperniki (hence their family name), near Nysa. Nysa is a Polish town today, but back in 1300s it was Czech. Kopernik’s branch of the family moved to Kraków in 1367 and then to ToruÅ„, as being merchants they were willing to trade with Teutonic Knights.

  2. Kopernik’s mother was Barbara de domo Watzenrod. A daughter of the rich ToruÅ„ lay judge, that supported the city with enourmous (as for these times) amount of money in their fight with Teutonic Knights. The family name is German, but unlike with Britain, that is an island, in Europe nations are mixing with each other so it’s not unusual to have the name typical for another nations. Just to do not look too far, Sarkozy, former French president’s surname is Hungarian. Current Czech president is Vaclav Klaus etc etc. But the political views of Łukasz Watzenrod states clearly part of which nation he considered himself.

  3. Kopernik himself was performing political functions in Prusy Królewskie (aka Königlich-Preußen or Polnische-Preußen) - the province that was under Polish King after Poland won the war with Teutonic Knights and signed Toruń peace treaty. Mikołaj Kopernik was a negotiator in political tensions between Poland and Teutonic Knights). He moved to Frombork, where apart from his political and church duties he was leading astronomical observations. During Polish-Teutonic war of 1520s, he was calling for Polish king to come and help and he personally wrote a letter.

So both family lines as well as political views of his parents and grandparents show clear that he was not filling at all related to Germany. But I am not surprised, that Germans try to say that Kopernik was German. I bet if I become a famous man who changed the fate of the world, Scots in 500 years woudl also try to claim that I was Scottish :slight_smile:

Now i’m sure you checked these facts thoroughly as indeed you did your others and VOSA are unfairly targeting EE trucks

Now I’m sure that you might reconsider your assumption, that I am wrong in everything I say.

bigvern1:
He’ll convince us Hitler was Polish next!

Even if I had a reason to do that, I am afraid I would fail in this task. Hitler was born in a family of Austro-Hungarian civil servant and his family had a long history of being German :slight_smile:

jayseabea:
I have to say Orys, I’m impressed with your persistance and belief in the power of reason over fear and prejudice.
I wish I had your talent for language and patience. You’re obviously educated to a higher level than most people on the list.This in itself will be taken as a disadvantage and treated with suspicion by the working class in Britain and, like it or not, lorry driving IS a working class job. Skilled yes, but NOT a “profession” in the accepted sense.
Keep it up.

Thanks for the nice words. It’s not my fault that because I happen to know more on some subject, they are more hostile towards me. I am always happy to learn, and trucknet was a great source of education for me.

billybigrig:
Many of the offences actually result from a lack of harmonisation. A vehicle that was legal for the first part of it’s journey may suddenly be 1,000kgs over weight on the pin. Sounds very dramatic but it’s well within manufacturers safe thresholds and that of other EU countries. You could also load up to 40,000kgs but forget that you will be filling up with a big chunk of diesel before crossing the channel.

I guess this might be a reason why the percentage is higher - the problem with disharmonisation. UK has very different regulation in many things, not only trucking. So yes, you might be right, this might be the reason why there is a bit higher percentage of the offences. I am sure that for the same reason UK trucks have slightly higher percentage of offences in France than French trucks…

Likewise with say the rules in regard to wing tops on mudguards and how VOSA call that one, so again legal perhaps until you get off the ferry.

Actually, VOSA cannot do nothing if vehicle is legal in country of registration. Vienna convention ensures it. Otherwise French and Dutch trucks with yellow headlights will have trouble everywhere they go, British style blue bulbs in contour lights will have to be replaced with white in Dover and it would be illegal to drive British or Irish vehicle in Poland or Latvia, because according to the law in this country, vehicle with steering wheel on the right side can’t get homologation. If VOSA targets foreign trucks for that they have their vehicles up to specifications in their own country, I am sure that there has to be something wrong with it.

Also the UK authorities have made great efforts to knock off things like per KM pay, unpaid waiting time etc where as that is, as you say, still prevalent in some EE countries. Despite a small minority of ■■■■■■■■ cowboys most UK operators are these days so [zb] scared of losing there O licence that things are squeakier clean than ever. In many instances the EE drivers who get caught are under tremendous pressure from employers in much the same way some of us were 10 or 20 years ago.

This is the thing I am trying to show you. These changes are happening also in Poland and they happen in much faster pace… At the moment many Polish companies are also looking very strict at legalities, especially since introducion of the new toll system that is used by ITD (Polish VOSA) to track truck’s movement and compare it with tacho records. Off course there is still many cowboys, but their percentage is much lower than most of trucknet users seem to think.

Moreover, as rightly spotted by Harry Monk in one of our previous discussions, Poland became a field of play for big players (just like Wolter Koops and likes) that think that they can exploit Polish drivers at the expense of both Polish and Western markets. Yes, still many of Polish truckers have to work for such outfits, but if you are good and have some experience, you can easily find a proper job in decent company - and that is still much, much easier than here in UK, while money, in some cases, can be even better. But go to any Polish forum and see: Working for Koops, Raben or Rico in the past is not the dream of Polish driver. If he will have a choice to go on the dole or go work for them, he will work, but as soon as he will get better job, he will be off that place without looking back.

As I’ve said with the immigration thing as a whole, it’s OK to hate the game but not the players. In this case the players are stuck in a bad but slowly improving game as we were once. :wink:

I am happy that we agree on that. :slight_smile:

Happy Polish Independence day, by the way :smiley:

Thank you :smiley:

One more thing:

Roadworthiness check results for 2008/9

See, this is another thing. Gas Gas claims to give you latest data. You operate on data 5 years old. You have to take into consideration that Poland is now in period of very rapid changes, 5 years in Poland economy is a whole epoque. This is what I tried to explain to trucknet in “operating truck from Eastern Europe” thread: Poland five years ago was completely different than it is now!

Wheel Nut:

jammymutt:
Wasnt Hitler jewish?

Remind me again is Jewish a nationality or a religion?

The fabled land of Jewshire is not on my map!

Thats because its a religion. I’m not aware of any current figures of them driving for Walter Koops, but its 100% a religion !! :laughing:

Mike-C:

Wheel Nut:

jammymutt:
Wasnt Hitler jewish?

Remind me again is Jewish a nationality or a religion?

The fabled land of Jewshire is not on my map!

Thats because its a religion. I’m not aware of any current figures of them driving for Walter Koops, but its 100% a religion !! :laughing:

You are wrong again. Judaism is religion. Jews are nation. I know a Jew who is an atheist.

Mike-C:
Sigh…The Ancient Greeks knew the Earth was not flat, they also knew it wasn’t the centre of the Universe ,not sure where you get these facts from. But if you have some spare time, pop over to Wikepidia and sort out the controversey for them as they seem to have some doubt that Kopernik was Polish, infact they think he was German.
Now i’m sure you checked these facts thoroughly as indeed you did your others and VOSA are unfairly targeting EE trucks

Sorry Mike, I just this second checked Wikipedia.
They have “Nicolaus Copernicus was born on 19 February 1473 in the city of ToruÅ„ (Thorn), in the province of Royal Prussia, in the Crown of the Kingdom of Poland.”
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikolaj_Kopernik

orys:

Also the UK authorities have made great efforts to knock off things like per KM pay, unpaid waiting time etc where as that is, as you say, still prevalent in some EE countries. Despite a small minority of ■■■■■■■■ cowboys most UK operators are these days so [zb] scared of losing there O licence that things are squeakier clean than ever. In many instances the EE drivers who get caught are under tremendous pressure from employers in much the same way some of us were 10 or 20 years ago.

This is the thing I am trying to show you. These changes are happening also in Poland and they happen in much faster pace… At the moment many Polish companies are also looking very strict at legalities, especially since introducion of the new toll system that is used by ITD (Polish VOSA) to track truck’s movement and compare it with tacho records. Off course there is still many cowboys, but their percentage is much lower than most of trucknet users seem to think.

Moreover, as rightly spotted by Harry Monk in one of our previous discussions, Poland became a field of play for big players (just like Wolter Koops and likes) that think that they can exploit Polish drivers at the expense of both Polish and Western markets. Yes, still many of Polish truckers have to work for such outfits, but if you are good and have some experience, you can easily find a proper job in decent company - and that is still much, much easier than here in UK, while money, in some cases, can be even better. But go to any Polish forum and see: Working for Koops, Raben or Rico in the past is not the dream of Polish driver. If he will have a choice to go on the dole or go work for them, he will work, but as soon as he will get better job, he will be off that place without looking back.

One more thing:

Roadworthiness check results for 2008/9

See, this is another thing. Gas Gas claims to give you latest data. You operate on data 5 years old. You have to take into consideration that Poland is now in period of very rapid changes, 5 years in Poland economy is a whole epoque. This is what I tried to explain to trucknet in “operating truck from Eastern Europe” thread: Poland five years ago was completely different than it is now!

Unfortunately it’s all I had available instantly and I would be confident that in so far as PL vehicles are concerned that the figures have dramatically improved :wink:

As I said earlier human nature will still judge by old form though. We have 2nd and 3rd generation Indian and Pakistani families, for example, still regarded by some as “those bloody foreigners takin’ all our bloody jobs” :open_mouth: :open_mouth: :open_mouth: :open_mouth: :frowning: :frowning: :frowning: That said do please bare in mind the damage to rates and losses incurred to the British and European hauliers when the operating costs were lower due in part to lower wages and social costs in Poland and the previous lack of enforcement. In the modern world with new technologies and greater sharing of information the playing field between, for example, Poland and the UK will become even more level. Especially with the rising social costs of the growing western economy you now have.

Poland is indeed in a period of great transition and modernisation to a more western standard. I can still remember what passed for roads, trucks and passing many horse and carts. Changing 20 quid for a sack full of Zlotty and speeding fines of about a quid :laughing: :laughing: It’s fascinating to see the new motorways and overall improvements. :smiley:

Could I ask what impact your less regulated neighbours are having on the Polish transport industry ■■?

I was chatting to a Polish lad on the ferry a few months ago and he was most animated about the Lithuanian, Latvian and Bulgarian companies and the damage they were doing to rates and wages :confused: :confused: :confused:

Harry Monk:

orys:
I know that they stop Britons TOO. It’s simply the scale that matters. Everytime I drive past open VOSA checkpoint, most of the trucks there are Eastern Europeans. Surely there is still more British trucks on British roads, so they should be a majority of the stopped ones?

Presumably that’s because eastern European trucks trigger the VOSA Viper more often then.

Or maybe VOSA have learned from experience that there is more likely to be something wrong with eastern European trucks? Or are you suggesting that VOSA are just institutionally racist?

:laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

I thought that was only an accepted defence in the case of Jamaican registered wagons caught doing cabotage here. :smiling_imp: :laughing: :laughing: