Nextdrop:
What Orys has failed to mention is back home for him they have big issues with chinesse labour working in ship repair yards and this is causing big issues and if you think we like a rumble try going to a Polish shipyard there has been all sorts of ‘accidents’ right wing ■■■■ based issues and i speak as some one who works direct for the likes of Skandi and Stena Drilling who put their boats in there.
No, i did not failed, I mentioned Ukrainian and Vietnamese workforce, the shipyards are rather marginal thing, alotugh I gues in your trade they play important role.
With the shipyards there is another issue, shipyards are viewed special, as, after all, it was the shipyards of Gdańsk in 1980 where communism started to falling down, therefore people see it as a symbol and Polish heritage and are very unhappy when shipyards are closed down or taken over by foreign labour force. The truth is though that we could not compete with fareast shipyards due to labour costs and, as someone mentioned, quality of work (because it is another problem that these shipyards that are still in Polish hands are full of trade union parasites and they paradoxally became an enclave of old Poland, as trade union do not allow any changes. Other enclaves are Polish railways, school system etc etc, but this is subject for another discussion).
Thank you that someone confirmed my words, so maybe now people stop telling me “you don’t know how is to have cheap labour in your country”.
Inselaffe:
This is not just a problem in Britain, it is the same across the whole of what was formerly known as “Western Europe” before The Wall came down.
… Although this is probably being abused on a massive scale across Europe, it serves to stem the tide somewhat. If it is abolished, the situation will become many times worse than at present.
This is very good analisys, I just have one thing to add:
It was good from Eastern European point of view, as Western Europe had 60 years to build their haulage industry, we started from scratch in 1990. So if one ever wanted that all European Countries will compete at the level field, there had to be created conditions when Eastern Europeans can build their industry quicker, in a manner of speaking, at the expense of their Western counterparts. But in a manner of speaking Western wealth is build at the expense of Eastern Europe suffering behind Iron Curtain, so altough I can see how the Western hauliers are feeling about that, there is some karma in it (or historical justice if you prefere) if you look at the wider view.
If it wasn’t like that and if we weren’t allowed to compete with you with our lower prices, the big players will just come to Eastern Europe and buy everything leaving these part of Europe without any hauling companies that stayed in Eastern European hands… I think you will agree that in a long run that would not be benefitial for anyone…
BUT
This analysis would be complete 10, max 5 years ago. We live in fast changing world and my invilvement in this thread is to show you, that recently there were some changes. Namely, the economical crisis happened. The small Eastern European companies grew and they are now big enough to be something more than just pawns in that game. Customers all over europe seek further discounts in the price, the big Western companies cannot offer them without further squeezing their Eastern European subcontractors. But these subcontractors have their costs significantly up (except for the Romanians and Bulgarians, lets just ignore them for the moment, I will come back to them later), wages went up, the number of drivers stabilised, awareness of the employee rights risen and average Bogdan will no longer accept the job in which he is away from home for months in the row. This was true 10 years ago, I remember hitchiking with the Polish trucker who recently changed his lorry from Renault Major to Scania and he was very unhappy because his only holidays were when the truck was broken down, and this scania never brokes down…
Nowadays, if you read the Polish trucking forum, the job market look completely different, most of the people work in a 3 weeks on, one week off or 4 weeks on, two weeks off basis, they earn twice as more as they were earning 10 years ago and so on. The jobs you describe off course still exist, but they are considered crap jobs, the companies still advertise for drivers, and just as in Britain, if someone constantly advertise for drivers it means that it is usually not worth to work there…
So, back to the companies: they decided that instead of being squeezed furthther by the big players and they try to unify into some power that can stand against them… Most of the players become of significant size over the years, and they are now working on something like your pallet networks etc, just for European transport…
Some Polish companies open their offices in UK and succesfully compete with the big players.
Now the Bulgarians and Romanians come and do what we done 10 years ago… But 10 years ago it was 15 Western Countries vs 10 cheap countries. Nowadays situation is different: Its 15 Western countries + 10 not so expensive countries vs 2 cheap countries… You cant see it, as we are still cheaper than you are, but when it comes to Bulgarians and Romanians we are already on your side… And as the costs in Poland are still growing fast, much faster than in Britain (over last 5 years diesel price in Britain rised about 40%, in Poland about 90%, the wages of the drivers in Poland rised significantly, in Britain they are still at the same level or even lower etc etc etc) you should be able to compete with Eastern Hauliers soon, in some cases (as I provided in this thread) you are already able to fight back.
So the level playing ground is to be here soon, be prepared to it! Don’t look at the world as it was here 10 years ago, maybe its not “GO!” stage yet, but it is certainly state of “Ready, Steady…”
There is growing animosity across the whole of western Europe to the eastern Europeans who are perceived to be stealing jobs by undercutting rates, while the main culprits are the greed orientated firms at the top of the food chain, who are mercilessly playing the EU game to maximise their own profits with scant regard for whom they harm in the process.
This is very interesting point, I think we should all stand against the greedy capitalists. We are the 99% and stuff
fly sheet:
I think Orys your playing the race card here, I last transited Poland in 1999, I have to also mention I was going to Poland when a Brit needed a visa to get in & my takes is its the capitalist private companies who have been the ruination of a good job,
So you base your opinion on Poland on what you saw 13 years ago? Poland has changed a lot, I am going to my home town once in a six months usually and I am always amazed how many changes I see… 13 years it is a looooooong time for Eastern Europe.
I take offence over your night trunking comments too, if it wasnt for the Poles, Czechs, Lits etc it wouldnt be so,
How you can take offence if I am talking about facts? At least I am not telling that all Britons don’t wash and cant drive
I could no longer compete with Your countrymen as I wasnt prepared to lower my standard of living to theres its that simple.
When there were money in that, British hauliers were going allover Middle East and as far as to Pakistan border. I doubt you have climatised space cabs and showers every 10 miles back then. So I guess it was the British drivers who lacked shower back then and might be looked at by the local drivers as “this dirty, bearded guys in their battered lorries”. Whats my point? My point is that you are as human as we are, and if there is money in spending two months in crap lorry, you will do it as much, as any other Polish driver.
Maybe Poland is different now but my veiw of the place is the same of Turnip & Harry,
Shame, you are smart guys, if you only wanted to open your eyes and look at reality, even if you believe in 30% of what I say, that could change your opinion dramatically…
I think your living in cloud cuckoo land really, and in fairness if it is the utopia you seem to describe
Unlike yous with your myths, I always try to support my points with concrete factual data.
wtf are you residing in the uk for
Because things that are interested in are better here than in Poland. But that does not mean, that EVERYTHING here is better than in Poland.
You seem to have turned this thread into an us & them
In case you haven’t noticed, this thread started from “us vs them”. I just defend “them” from “you”, as your perception of “them” is based on some myths, not on facts.
which in my day we all helped each other once we crossed the border & it didnt matter where you was from,
It is still like that in Eastern Europe… When I have problem on the road, I always can turn to any Eastern European truck and ask for help. I bet any English person can do it as well… But when I am trying to ask something from British truck, my Polish accent often stands in the way and I am just told to bugger of.
How many Soviets do you see nowadays in the west now? Your Polish colleagues have even undercut them lot too.
Now thats one of the best craps in that thread so far.
- Soviet union ceased to exist in 1991. If you mean “trucks from former soviet union” there is plenty - all LT, LV and EST trucks come from former Soviet Union.
- If you mean “Russian trucks” - this is a result of Russian Politics. They wanted their hauliers to do all the job, so they issue a permits for foreign countries who want to transport goods into Russia. The number of this permits is limited. Therefore EU countries answered with the same and issue permits for Russian trucks, limiting their number on our roads.
- If you mean Belarussian and Ukrainian - There is plenty of Ukrainian trucks even of British roads. As for Belarussian, this is enclave of the totalitarian regime in Europe, their economy is in pieces, and Belarussian truck is as rare thing as EE hauliers in West pre-1989
Btw This Russian thing is actually a good lesson for this, who say foreign hauliers should be banned from UK: Yeah, Russian have exclusive rights to their market, but they lost access to European market. Was it worth it?