This is a post that could go on and on as there are so many things to be taken into account and it isn’t really a quick answer. Have a read through the DFT Code of Practice for Safety Of Loads On Vehicles - it can be heavy going. it’s a 123 pages for a start. www2.dft.gov.uk/pgr/roads/vehicl … hicles.pdf
In my opinion the lines of stitching in a strap ‘can’ indicate the SWL of the strap. 5 lines equals 5 tonnes etc. There should be a lable clarifying the SWL but they have a habit of going missing. Obviously you NEED to know the working limit of the restraining device before you can calculate what you need to use - so yes labels or stamps and tags etc should be there but the stitching is a good indicator.
The load should be secured to withstand 100% of its weight in a forward direction and 50% in a sideways and rearwards direction. The load should also be secured in a vertical direction but usually if forward, sideways and rearward are taken care of then vertical will be as well.
It is recommended that lashing assemblies manufactured to BS 5759 are used. So the guide only says recommended. But all the way through the guide it uses words such as suitable and sufficient - it is up to the user to know what is suitable and sufficient.
The 9t load would have needed at least one ‘lashing’ every 1.5 m along it’s length. (as is the case for any load)
If you used three straps evenly spaced and these were at least 3t capacity each and attached to anchorage points of at least 1.5t capacity along each side (so 6 anchorage points) then I reckon you pretty much had it covered (but mind those 1.5t capacity anchorage points with that 3t ratchet set - would be best if the anchorage point was a higher capacity than the strap or you may overtighten the strap and damage the anchorage point). as this equates to a total capacity of 9t (5 anchorage points of 1.5t). if the load wasn’t against the headboard then you may actually need a bit more force to prevent forward movement but 9t of force on a 9t load should be sufficient.
Chances are you used three 5t strap sets (although often the ratchets are of a lesser rating than the webbing) and secured these directly to the chassis so the anchorage points were way in excess of the 1.5t required or even the 5t ratchet sets.
You could have used two 5t straps anchored to a 5t point on each side - this would give your minimum 10t restraint when sufficiently tensioned. But it is recommended to have at least 3 anchorage points on each side of a load. Front, centre and rear.
Obviously Rope hooks should not be used to anchor loads. Rope hooks are not subject to constructional standards, and so they vary in strength, size and material content and are rarely designed to withstand forces exceeding about 1-1.5 tonnes. Many fall far short of this strength being so weak that they can be distorted by applying a ratchet buckle to tighten a webbing strap.
If your vehicle had anchorage points built in - these must be rated and secured to the chassis. a 5t ring bolted through the wood aint no use. I would always anchor straps/chains to the chassis where possible.
of course you would have inspected your straps for signs of wear and tear and not used a frayed, cut or knotted strap. You would have checked the end hook and ratchet for signs of damage or corrosion.
The DFT guide does not say it should be chains here or straps there (or at least I haven’t spotted this bit). it only says the restraint should be strong enough to hold the load.
Obviously a chain with the right fittings and on the right anchorage points is far stronger than a strap. But no point having three 25t chains holding down a 9t load when straps are fine. Of course you would ensure the straps weren’t subject to chaffing or wear etc that would weaken them during the journey.
The three straps I have mentioned are of course a minimum. You should ensure that should a lashing/securing device come loose - the other lashings/securing devices aren’t affected and the overall restraining ‘effort’ is not reduced. So if you added a fourth strap - and one came a bit loose you would still meet the requirment of 100% of the weight forward, 50% sideways etc etc
The DFT guide is an excellent read for drivers and covers most types of loads. great to show the boss when he says 1 strap will do.
As quoted elsewhere in this thread there are some complicated calculations can be carried out to work out what load restraint is needed. i did all this on a course at the Health & Safety Laboratory in Buxton. very good course and delivered by the same people that advise the HSE. The angle of any straps or restraints can greatly increase the force you would need to apply to restrain the load - but this is too complext to go into here. its all in the guide
The short of it is - you secured the load and used a sensible amount of straps - that’s good.
The fact the load stayed on the trailer indicates you got it right.
Had the load fallen off - you had clearly got it wrong no matter what you used. the law in this instance is pretty absolute. if it is no longer on the wagon you didn’t restrain it sufficiently
As long as you never think “The weight will hold it”. In most cases, the heavier it is the easier it will move.
I stand by to be insulted, shot down and blatantly corrected. 