Were The Continental Lorry's Much Better?

gingerfold:
Saviem has given an excellent summary.

Just a few more thoughts for discussion. When Volvo entered the UK lorry market in '67 they already sold cars here (B18 / Amazon) in small numbers and these had a very good reputation. So was there a perception that because Volvo cars were good then their lorries would also be good? Contrast the situation less than 10 years later with British Leyland, i.e. rubbish cars therefore rubbish lorries.

Ramone is quite correct. Motorway running placed completely new strains on designs that were better suited to steady running on A roads, and even many of the main trunk routes were still single carriageways in the early '60s. Although, for example, the AEC/ Leyland/ Albion Ergomatic cab ranges were marketed as new models at the 1964 Commercial Motor Show in reality they contained many components that were updated versions of earlier designs. For instance Leyland Power Plus engines had been introduced in 1960/61. AEC AV760 and AV505 units contained new design features but could trace their origins back to the 1950s. The Ergomatic cab was a “one size fits all” concept, acceptable for models with AEC AV505 or Leyland 400 engines, but too small for Mandators and Beavers with AV760 and Power Plus 680 units. This cab design limited radiator coolant capacity and restricted airflow around the engines resulting in overheating and reliability problems even in the UK, but especially so in demanding climates such as Australia and South Africa, where AEC and Leyland had enjoyed strong sales for many years.The standard offerings of the new Continental marques offered turbo-charged engines and multi-ratio gearboxes. AEC and Leyland did offer multi-ratio gearboxes but as optional extras at additional cost.

The demise of Leyland and its subsidiary companies is a story that still has to be told. There was on-going research and development on new, high power output engines beginning in the early '60s, the AEC V8 covered in another thread that was killed off by Leyland when AEC claimed that it had sorted out the design faults. I recently disposed of all my authentic research data for the turbocharged AEC V8 rated at 350 bhp in 1971. The disastrous Leyland fixed head 500 series was a design too far for the technology and manufacturing capabilities of the time. The rejection rate for 500 engines on the production line was 35%, and the failure rate in service was unsustainable. All in all it’s a very sorry tale.

^
Yet more stereotypical bs. :unamused: :unamused: :laughing:

And in 1967 there were’nt many sensible bank robbers or coppers who’d have been driving a zb Volvo to get away from the scene of the crime or to catch the miscreants instead of a Jag. :open_mouth: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

So where’s all your research data which shows that a V8 Detroit powered TM would’nt have been as good at running up the motorway,compared to the competition,as that Jag was compared to it’s competition at the time :question: :question: .

I go to Italy every year on holiday and see plenty of old fiats iveco turbostars and a fair few old v8 scans but I’ve never seen a Bedford.

The bank robbers lost it by the 70s as Jack Regans granada always caught them lol

Carryfast:
^
Yet more stereotypical bs. :unamused: :unamused: :laughing:

■■?
Reads more like a reasoned and factual assessment to me than ‘bs’, but there you go.

Carryfast:
And in 1967 there were’nt many sensible bank robbers or coppers who’d have been driving a zb Volvo to get away from the scene of the crime or to catch the miscreants instead of a Jag. :open_mouth: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: .

I think he was making a point about perceived reliability and build quality rather than a ‘Sweeney style bank job’ getaway?.
The Jaguars that were built in the BL pre John Egan stewardship all suffered from exactly the same quality issues that plagued the reputation of the Princess, Allegro and Marina.
Btw - Hampshire Police ran Volvo cars on motorway patrol from the late 60’s.

Carryfast:
So where’s all your research data which shows that a V8 Detroit powered TM would’nt have been as good at running up the motorway,compared to the competition,as that Jag was compared to it’s competition at the time :question: :question: .

Some respect where it is due is needed here please.
Gingerfold has dedicated more years to factual and unbiased commercial vehicle research than anybody on this forum.
Comments like these are not constructive.

You are quite entitled to your very high opinion of the V8 Bedford TM if you have experienced good service from them yourself as an operator or driver.

Thanks for your support and kind comments ERF, much appreciated. I’m not fazed by Carryfast’s viewpoint, everone is entitled to an opinion and disagreements lead to lively and interesting debate. Although Carryfast looks like being hard work to convince!!!

ERF has understood my perception of build quality re. Volvo. So to pick up on Carryfast’s Jaguar reference the direct lorry comparison is Guy Big J… No further comment needed I think :stuck_out_tongue:

gingerfold:
Thanks for your support and kind comments ERF, much appreciated. I’m not fazed by Carryfast’s viewpoint, everone is entitled to an opinion and disagreements lead to lively and interesting debate. Although Carryfast looks like being hard work to convince!!!

No, he’s just hard work! Your reputation and record as a transport historian does rather put him in the shade. The dark side of the moon would be the best shade for him… :wink:

gingerfold:
Thanks for your support and kind comments ERF, much appreciated. I’m not fazed by Carryfast’s viewpoint, everone is entitled to an opinion and disagreements lead to lively and interesting debate. Although Carryfast looks like being hard work to convince!!!

ERF has understood my perception of build quality re. Volvo. So to pick up on Carryfast’s Jaguar reference the direct lorry comparison is Guy Big J… No further comment needed I think :stuck_out_tongue:

Are you an author of several AEC publications and an ex owner of a Spiers Mandator by any chance■■?

ramone:

gingerfold:
Thanks for your support and kind comments ERF, much appreciated. I’m not fazed by Carryfast’s viewpoint, everone is entitled to an opinion and disagreements lead to lively and interesting debate. Although Carryfast looks like being hard work to convince!!!

ERF has understood my perception of build quality re. Volvo. So to pick up on Carryfast’s Jaguar reference the direct lorry comparison is Guy Big J… No further comment needed I think :stuck_out_tongue:

Are you an author of several AEC publications and an ex owner of a Spiers Mandator by any chance■■?

Sounds like it -

Carryfast needs to wind his neck in a little!

Suedehead:
One marque that deserves a mention , has gotta be the Unic/Fiat big V of the late 60s/early 70s :slight_smile: mutts nutts in their day apparentley.
Never drove one meself . . . anybody on here ever drive one ?

We ran several Turbostars in the late 80`s and 1 had the V8 in it wow that could pull but everything just fell off from door handles electric windows that just dropped down and had to be wedged shut,but the engines (6 and 8 cylinder) were bullet proof but the interior of the cabs had poor build quality

I am sat on my hands watching this thread with interest. The future’s bright, the futures Ginger :stuck_out_tongue:

Wheel Nut:
I am sat on my hands watching this thread with interest. The future’s bright, the futures Ginger :stuck_out_tongue:

I think since Gingerfold and Saviem have joined in the debate Carryfast has been totally outgunned.He should get his seconds to throw the towel in,before he gets a technical KO.

ramone:

gingerfold:
Thanks for your support and kind comments ERF, much appreciated. I’m not fazed by Carryfast’s viewpoint, everone is entitled to an opinion and disagreements lead to lively and interesting debate. Although Carryfast looks like being hard work to convince!!!

ERF has understood my perception of build quality re. Volvo. So to pick up on Carryfast’s Jaguar reference the direct lorry comparison is Guy Big J… No further comment needed I think :stuck_out_tongue:

Are you an author of several AEC publications and an ex owner of a Spiers Mandator by any chance■■?

Yes, guilty as charged on both accusations.

kr79:
The bank robbers lost it by the 70s as Jack Regans granada always caught them lol

No Jack Regan’s state of the art new Granada only just about managed to catch the 10 year old,at the time, bog standard,knackered S Types because by then they were cheap enough to buy to be able to afford to wreck them.

However luckily for Regan and the Ford publicity lot none of those Jags was fitted with a race tune 4.5 Litre XK motor running on triple webers let alone a XJ 12 fitted with a manual box and a 6 or 7 Litre motor. :open_mouth: :laughing: .

Dave the Renegade:

Wheel Nut:
I am sat on my hands watching this thread with interest. The future’s bright, the futures Ginger :stuck_out_tongue:

I think since Gingerfold and Saviem have joined in the debate Carryfast has been totally outgunned.He should get his seconds to throw the towel in,before he gets a technical KO.

If that’s the case maybe I’ll get an answer to that question concerning the F88 versus the F10/12 versus the TM 3800/4400. :unamused: and the KW circus wagon with 450 hp versus those French heaps doing ‘european operations’. :open_mouth: :laughing: :laughing:

ERF:

Carryfast:
^
Yet more stereotypical bs. :unamused: :unamused: :laughing:

■■?
Reads more like a reasoned and factual assessment to me than ‘bs’, but there you go.

Carryfast:
And in 1967 there were’nt many sensible bank robbers or coppers who’d have been driving a zb Volvo to get away from the scene of the crime or to catch the miscreants instead of a Jag. :open_mouth: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: .

I think he was making a point about perceived reliability and build quality rather than a ‘Sweeney style bank job’ getaway?.
The Jaguars that were built in the BL pre John Egan stewardship all suffered from exactly the same quality issues that plagued the reputation of the Princess, Allegro and Marina.
Btw - Hampshire Police ran Volvo cars on motorway patrol from the late 60’s.

Carryfast:
Gingerfold has dedicated more years to factual and unbiased commercial vehicle research than anybody on this forum.
Comments like these are not constructive.

You are quite entitled to your very high opinion of the V8 Bedford TM if you have experienced good service from them yourself as an operator or driver.

Better than that I saw what they performed like built as fire trucks used for saving lives not just delivering freight.Except unlike the yanks they were built to go even faster than American type fire trucks built using the same type of Detroit engines because someone here came up with the better idea of using proper manual boxes in them instead of zb Allison autos with torque converters. :bulb: :smiley:

altitude:
I’m sure Carryfast will put us all right on this one :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

One week later and you were spot on John :unamused: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: .

Saviem:
Hello all, dont want to be boring but I think that Carryfasts unremiting love of all things Detroit needs a little historical context adding. Gingerfold is quite right in setting the scene,in legislative and historic terms, but lets look at why products are produced and how they reach the market. Post WW11 export or die was the position, look how many markets our manufacturers featured in, and not just Commonwealth countries, and how strong was the following. Collaboration in Europe, Willeme/AEC and BMC in France, Licence built Gardners for Bernard, Leyland with DAF, no major quality issues but what happened at home? The impact of the 1964 Transport Act was enormous, the transport market was completly opened up, and product supply was a major problem. Assemblers could not source components due to production and labour problems, (remember just how bad they were). No two vehicles off the line were the same, (in my office I still have three Atkinson Borderer parts manuals, considering all three were ■■■■■■■ 205 Eaton RTO610 spec the difference in detail is breathtaking . Warranty issues were enormous and chaotic, sometimes it was the manufacturers responsibility, other times the component supplier, pity the poor operator! Ever been a young hopeful entering the portals of a Main Distributor wanting to buy a lorry? then you will remember the disdain with which you were treated. 12months delivery would be quoted, or longer, every thing would be pre sold, no hope son, “but weve a second hand” So the imports arrived, some via operators who had suffered the laissez fair attitude of UK Distributors and manufacturers,Jim McKelvie with Volvo, Mercedes with Normand, Frank Tinsdale with Magirus Deutz, MAN with TKM, Scania via independent Concessionaires Berliet with Citroen Citax, the list can go on and on. Individually no threat to our domestic manufacturers, but collectivly the impact on home market share of the TIV (total industry volume, the means by which market penetration and share is measured by new chassis registration) was significant. Why? well the majority of importers appointed fledgling Dealer networks, some operators, some repairers, some investors, but they all shared one thing, they were hungry for success, they needed that new sale, and any customer was well looked after. Personal contact sold many vehicles, and provided that the client was well supported in aftersales the product became almost secondary to the business relationship. In themselves not all products were better than their UK equivelent,but almost universally the attitude of the Dealers staff, and the Importer was more receptive and positive the customer was king, something very new in our industry. The volume Distributors of UK product, Ford, Bedford, Dodge, really did not view the importers as a serious threat, they did not in the main compete in the same market segment most importers concentrating on the booming Tractor market post 1964 Transport Act. ?(When they did it was too late, a parallel of the UK motorcycle industry and the Japanese)! The assemblers, well they produced a reasonable quality product, and could sell their production capacity, and more, so why worry! oh dear oh dear! And what of Leyland? I am amazed that no insider has ever written a true expose of what really did happen! it would be a best seller. Political interference leading to irrational decision making, poor R&D To many competing products, Distributors, Production Plants, many can speculate, but no one really knows, all we know is that product and service deteriorated and importers sliced up the Leyland client base. What a tragedy in National, Human,and Industry terms. So in broad terms “Were the Continental lorries much better” No. but their UK Dealers were more active, had shorter lines of communication to the Importer, or Concessionaire, and thence to the Factory. They could respond to a problem more quickly, and positivley, and the customer was in the main happy, and remained loyal to the brand.My dear Gentlemen, you will have noted that I have not resorted to individual vehicle comparison in my missive, but now I must respond to Carryfasts opinions. The F88 Volvo was not over rated, as many who enjoy this forum, and have experienceof this vehicle in the 60s and 70s will explain. 230 240 8 or the sensational 16speed, F FB or G models.The Italian market,(of which I have some experience) mainly concentrated in the Northern Industrial areas, in the 70s to 90s one of the highest concentrations of owner drivers and small operators in Europe.Biggest seller in the tractor market in the 70s, Fiat 170.35 350HP 13 speed Fuller 4x2 (suedehead if ever you get a chance to drive one in preservation do so!! they are wonderful! (and re exporting new ones back to Italy earned many pounds for UK Fiat dealers in the 70s, much to the dispair of dear late Dr Giovanni Brasca in Grosvenor Square).Followed by Scania V8, vOLVO, MAN, Saviem Berliet, Mercedes, Bedford hardly figured! True they sold some, but reliability issues, did not help sales. American specifications, Carryfast this is an old chesnut,In retirement in the 90s I indulged an old interest and started to import US trucks, cab overs and conventionals. Mainly ■■■■■■■ Fuller Rockwell, easy specs. My one mistake was two K100 long coffin cab 8V92 DDA 13 speed od Fullers with 8 bag air. Love the sound, what horrible (no Orrible lorries) totally unsuited to European application.They ended up with a French Circus, I hope the Lions enjoyed them. As for American operations, my eyes were opened in the 80s whilst working there, seeing the day shift clocking on carrying blow up seat cushions, plug in CBs as they made their way over to the still warm K100s 86inch BBC tractors, then 20years old!! Its all about productivity and profit, not day dreams dear friend!!Sorry to go on so long, Cheerio bye bye.

Don’t worry, its never bothered Carryfast. Sorry, I was desperately trying to sit on my hands like Wheelnut but sometimes…Well, you know :smiley:

Dave the Renegade:

altitude:
I’m sure Carryfast will put us all right on this one :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

One week later and you were spot on John :unamused: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: .

:wink: :laughing: Someone’s got to do it.

Carryfast:

Dave the Renegade:

altitude:
I’m sure Carryfast will put us all right on this one :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

One week later and you were spot on John :unamused: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: .

:wink: :laughing: Someone’s got to do it.

You could rewrite this Carryfast the Second Epistle to the Corinthians.

Dave the Renegade:

Carryfast:

Dave the Renegade:

altitude:
I’m sure Carryfast will put us all right on this one :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

One week later and you were spot on John :unamused: :laughing: :laughing: :laughing: .

:wink: :laughing: Someone’s got to do it.

You could rewrite this Carryfast the Second Epistle to the Corinthians.

They could re title Saviem’s post as war and peace.But even if it was twice as long as that it still won’t make that Renault (or F88) any faster. :open_mouth: