The following I had intended over one posts but due to length I intend to split into two
Part 2 Foden ERF Atkinson
The following are my thoughts and comments not based on any scientific evidence just my views and thoughts based on information passed to me and my experience in my years in road haulage.
We ran 1 Foden with Rolls Royce diesel engine
1 Atkinson with 180 Gardner engine
Several ERF with Gardner Engines
Fibreglass cabs
I have heard criticism of fibreglass cabs. We had a history of running various light weight pantecnicons with Marsden and Van Plan coachwork with integral fibreglass cabs
I the case of Bedford SB,s and Seddon Peninine which had complete fibreglass which were trouble free, also several others such as Bedford TK which were based on the Chassis scuttles and in these cases the only problems were the bits of tin that was provided by the chassis manufacturers that was hidden within the fibreglass rotting.
I have over the years heard arguments that the fibreglass cab wasn’t as safe during impact in accidents. In my experience this is untrue as when we had fairly serious accidents with cab impact the cabs didn’t suffer the damage that one could expect by fibreglass disintegrating, and the drivers safety was always protected, and in any event with today’s advances with the likes of carbon fibre it would be easy to build a fibreglass cab that is much stronger than any steel cab.
However from my knowledge all steel cabs suffered from rotting and in many cases the effects of this on the strength of the cab has never been investigated, but I suspect the cab rot sets in much earlier than we can see with the human eye, so steel cabs will not always give the protection they were originally designed to offer.
Large manufacturers like Mercedes, Scania, and Volvo etc can afford the crash test their products however coachbuilders like Marsden and I suspect smaller manufacturers like ERF, Foden and Atkinson also had limited funds.
Had they had the opportunity I think the tests would have turned out favourable.
One thing is that you never would see a rusting fibreglass cab. Personally I don’t think Foden was as nice looking or as well finished as Atkinson or ERF but if grants had been made available to these manufacturers I am sure their products could have been made even better
Mergers and takeovers.
We operated several Seddon vehicles and I have said in previous threads that although they were more expensive than Bedfords they were not that much better.
In my opinion they could not compare with Atkinson. I have heard rumours that Leyland through shares they owned were able to influence the merger between Seddon and Atkinson and I wouldn’t be surprised because it seems to me that Leyland Motors have done more than any other organisation to destroy the British commercial vehicle manufacturing industry.
I think that Atkinson should have been encouraged by grants etc to stay as an individual company. The three companies should have been encouraged with government financial injections to remain independent and competitive.
I believe that they should have also been encouraged to get together in a company that was jointly owned and funded by the government for research and development. None of the three companies were large enough to spend in this area anything like the investment to compete with the foreign manufacturers. They needed help and encouragement. But common sense tells us that they started from a better position making superior products to the European competition.
It’s easy to say that due to common market laws the government wasn’t allowed to give financial grants. That is rubbish as all European countries apart from UK manage to find their way round this and any grants given would have been refunded over and over if we had emerged with a strong vehicle building industry. What would have happened if a British Company had wanted to take over Daimler Benz commercial vehicle manufacturing?
Emission and Engine Building:
We had probably with Gardner the finest diesel engine manufacturer this world will ever see.
I personally don’t believe in Global warming and think it is evolution of the planet that will happen whatever we do but again applying common sense what is the most economic diesel engine giving the best MPG ever produced?
If the Gardner Engines were not wasting fuel they must have been half way there with emissions. Once again they were a small company and needed financial help to develop their products. I’m sure over the years like everyone else they had been taxed excessively to pay for the follies of British Leyland Motor Corporation. When payback time came and they needed help to modernise and further improve their engine design where was our government?
Economic Consequences:
I trained as a mathematician not an economist but when I hear of what happened to the factories never mind the jobs it makes me feel disgust.
About 5 years ago my I had to go near Sandbach in Cheshire and my dad went out for a ride with me. It was his last journey outside of county Durham and one of the last few car journeys he made. We enjoyed the day and I am very pleased I took him. We had lunch in a pub on the outskirts of Sandbach and because of his age he was cold and started to shake. Seeing this landlord came over and poked the coal fire and put on a bit extra coal. I asked him where was ERF’s factory. ‘Oh that’s been knocked down and they have built a Lidel shop on the site, together with car park’
I read on one of the threads on this site that Foden has been demolished and housing is being built on the site.
I don’t know what has happened over at Preston but no doubt something equally daft.
When will politicians learn that we need manufacturing jobs ideally exporting where possible but if that is not possible fuelling the British Market and not taking our money out of our country to pay for German or Swedish wealth?
The money that will be paid out over the next years to pay for unemployment and other benefits that are necessary because of the wilful destruction of our commercial vehicle industry would never have been needed had our government invested a small amount into our commercial Vehicle Industry.
They soon found the money for the banks, who in my opinion would have soon pulled themselves together and been self sufficient had Northern Rock been left to go down. That shock would have proved an immediate remedy.
Fair enough all was lost at Leyland. Let them rot in hell but the rest should have been saved.
In the next few days I will give my opinion on Bedford.